MLB: Pirates vs Rays Odds, and Prop Bets (May 4)

By · Updated 1 year ago
  • Pittsburgh has had a fantastic start, currently sitting at 20-10.
  • The Rays continue to be the best team in the entire MLB, at 24-6.
  • Tampa Bay is 10-9 in their all-time history against the Pittsburgh Pirates.

The Pirates and the Rays face off in an interesting interleague bout. Both teams have surpassed their expectations so far this season, earning 1st place spots in their divisions. There are key bets on both sides.

How to Watch

  • Where: Tropicana Field, St. Petersburg, FL
  • When: Thursday, May 4, 2023, at 1:10 p.m ET
  • How to Watch: Bally Sports

Prop Bets

Prop BetOdds
Conner Joe Over 0.5 Hits
Conner Joe Under 0.5 Hits


Conner Joe has had a fantastic start to the 2023 season. He is currently hitting .298, and has an OPS of .987, which ranks 12th in all of Major League Baseball. Joe is taking full advantage of his increased role in his first season with the Pirates. He’s gotten a hit in 4 of his last 5 games, and reached base in all 5. In Tuesday’s loss against the Rays, Joe went 2 for 4. I like his chances of getting another hit in this game.


Prop BetOdds
Bryan Reynolds Over 0.5 RBIs
Bryan Reynolds Under 0.5 RBIs


Bryan Reynolds is also having a key impact for the Pirates in their hot start, ranking 8th in the MLB with a .330 batting average, and a strong .957 OPS. Reynolds has followed a strange pattern over his career. In odd seasons (2019, 2021, 2023), he batted .315 with a .916 OPS. In even seasons (2020, 2022), he batted .225 with an OPS of .720. Injuries played a role in that, but I see Reynolds continuing his strong 2023 here.

August 14 2022 San Francisco CA, U.S.A. Pittsburgh center fielder Bryan Reynolds 10rounds third base after hitting a home run during MLB, Baseball Herren, USA NL west game between the Pittsburgh Pirates and the San Francisco Giants. San Francisco beat the Pirates 8-7 at Oracle Park San Francisco Calif. / CSM San Francisco USA - ZUMAc04_ 20220814_zaf_c04_053 Copyright: xThurmanxJamesx


Prop BetOdds
Zach Eflin Over 5.5 Strikeouts
Zach Eflin Under 5.5 Strikeouts


Zach Eflin has pitched very well so far this season, giving up 7 earned runs in 21 IP, equivalent to a 3.00 ERA. Eflin hasn’t had the best length, throwing an average of 74 pitches in his 4 starts thus far. This has resulted in a lower strikeout total, despite his strong performances. Against a Pirates team that has been strong on offense all season so far, I see Eflin pitching relatively well, but failing to amass more than 5 K’s.


Keith McCarthy
Contributor Keith McCarthy is an experienced sports analyst with a passion for predicting the outcomes of games spanning across sports such as football, basketball, baseball, and hockey, with a special expertise in college sports.