Yankees vs Blue Jays Odds, and Prop Bets (May 18)

By · Updated 1 year ago
  • The Yankees are starting to heat up, currently sitting at 25-19.
  • Toronto improved to 24-18, remaining tied with the Yankees.
  • New York is 383-317 in their all-time history against the Blue Jays.

The Yankees and Blue Jays face off in a crucial AL East matchup. Both teams are hanging tough in a brutal division, but have a lot of work to do to climb to the top of the standings. There are key bets on both sides.

How to Watch

  • Where: Rogers Centre, Toronto, ON
  • When: Thursday, May 18, 2023, at 7:07 p.m ET
  • How to Watch: YES

Prop Bets

Prop BetOdds
Daulton Varsho Over 0.5 Hits
Daulton Varsho Under 0.5 Hits


Dalton Varsho is having a rough start to his season. Through 41 games, he’s hitting just .216 from the plate. Varsho has hit some big home runs when he makes contact, but his ability to put the bat on the ball has been very inconsistent. In the last week, he went just 2 for 24 (.083). Even against a struggling pitcher in Nestor Cortes, I’d feel pretty good about taking the under in hits here for Varsho, especially with plus odds.


Prop BetOdds
Nestor Cortes Over 5.5 Ks
Nestor Cortes Under 5.5 Ks


Nestor Cortes has fallen far from repeating his dominance of last season, still working through some troubles in his game. He currently has a 5.53 ERA on the year, after giving up 6 runs in 4.1 innings to the Rays in his last start. Despite, Cortes’ struggles, he’s still picked up 6 or more strikeouts in 4 of his 8 starts this season. He only got 3 and 4 in the last two games, but I see him bouncing back with 6 Ks in this game.

April 29 20261: New York first baseman Nestor Cortes 65 throws a pitch during the game with New York Yankees and Kansas City Royals held at Kauffman Stadium in Kansas City Mo. David Seelig/Cal Medi Kansas City USA - ZUMAc04_ 20210429_zaf_c04_268 Copyright: xDavidxSeeligx/xCalxSportxMediax
IMAGO/Cal Media


Prop BetOdds
Kevin Kiermaier Over 0.5 RBIs
Kevin Kiermaier Under 0.5 RBIs


Kevin Kiermaier is having another great season, hitting .327 with a .909 OPS thus far. Kiermaier’s consistency at the plate has made him a real weapon in Toronto’s batting lineup. He’s been scorching hot as of late. It his last 10 games, Kiermaier is 15 for 38 (.455) at the plate. While hits don’t always guarantee RBIs, it’s much more likely to happen when he’s hitting that well. Against a struggling Cortes, I like the over.


Keith McCarthy
Contributor Keith McCarthy is an experienced sports analyst with a passion for predicting the outcomes of games spanning across sports such as football, basketball, baseball, and hockey, with a special expertise in college sports.