Expert prediction
MLB: Guardians vs Yankees Odds, and Prop Bets (May 3)
- Keith McCarthy
- May 2, 2023 at 9:18 PM EDT
Pick rationale
Analysis & key factors
- The Yankees have fallen to last place in the AL East, after a slow start.
- Cleveland is below .500, but remains in 2nd place in a weak AL Central.
- New York is 1153-910 in their all-time history against the Cleveland Guardians.
The Yankees and the Guardians will take each other on in a key AL bout. Both teams have been struggling, and will be aiming to heat back up in this series. There are some key bets to take a look at on both sides.
How to Watch
- Where: Yankee Stadium, Bronx, NY
- When: Wednesday, May 3, 2023, at 7:05 p.m ET
- How to Watch: YES
Prop Bets
| Prop Bet | Odds |
| Jose Trevino Over 0.5 Hits | |
| Jose Trevino Under 0.5 Hits |
Prediction:
Jose Trevino has been a key player for the Yankees since joining their team last season. In addition to winning the 2022 Platinum Glove for Catchers, Trevino has had surprisingly strong offensive play. He’s been especially hot at the plate lately, going 6 for 18 (.333) over the last week. He’ll face a tough opposing pitcher in Shane Bieber, but I like his chances of getting at least one hit before the game has concluded.
Pick:
| Prop Bet | Odds |
| Steven Kwan Over 0.5 RBIs | |
| Steven Kwan Under 0.5 RBIs |
Prediction:
Steven Kwan had a fantastic rookie year with the Guardians last season, posting a .298 batting average in 147 games played. He’s off to another strong start this year, hitting .278 with 7 stolen bases through 29 games. Kwan’s position as the leadoff hitter makes his odds of earning RBIs a bit lower, but he’s still picked up 11 this season already. Against a struggling Clarke Schmidt, I see Kwan driving in at least one run here.

Pick:
| Prop Bet | Odds |
| Shane Bieber Over 4.5 Strikeouts | |
| Shane Bieber Under 4.5 Strikeouts |
Prediction:
Shane Bieber has pitched well this year, posting a 3.11 ERA through 6 starts. He made it through 6 or more innings in 5 of those starts, proving his ability to make it deep into the game. Conversely, Bieber has not earned many strikeouts, getting more than 4 in only 1 start. In each of his last 4 games, Bieber finished with 4 K’s. Against the strikeout prone Yankees, without Aaron Judge, Bieber should surpass that mark.
Pick:
MLB
More Predictions
World Series: Rays vs. Brewers Game 4 Picks, Odds & Betting Analysis
There is a sense of inevitability in the 2026 World Series, as Milwaukee Brewers require just one more victory to win the biggest MLB honor for the first time. History will be against the Tampa Bay Rays, as no team has ever recovered from 3-0 down to win the World Series. You can find the […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read
World Series: Rays vs. Brewers Game 3 Picks, Odds & Betting Analysis
The intense action in the World Series steps up a gear on Monday, as the first game of the series to see the Tampa Bay Rays have home-field advantage will be staged. It will be a must-win encounter for the hosts, following defeats in Games 1 and 2 at American Family Field. A victory for […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read
World Series: Brewers vs. Rays Game 2 Picks, Odds & Betting Analysis
The intensity increases in the World Series on Saturday evening, as Game 2 between the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays is set for American Family Field. Milwaukee will be hoping for a fast start in their opening two games, but the Rays have been consistent on their travels in the postseason. The latest odds […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read
World Series: Brewers vs. Rays Game 1 Picks, Odds & Betting Analysis
The high-pressure action in the MLB reaches new heights on Oct. 23, as the 2026 World Series gets underway. Both the Tampa Bay Rays and Milwaukee Brewers will be targeting first honors, and whichever team deals with the pressure the best will likely seize the advantage. The Brewers will have the Game 1 home-field advantage, and you […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read
World Series 2026: Brewers vs. Rays Picks, Series Odds & Betting Analysis
History awaits in the MLB postseason, as a first-time World Series champion will be crowned in 2026. The Tampa Bay Rays are hoping that it’s their third time lucky, having lost in the 2008 and 2020 World Series, while the Milwaukee Brewers chase a first honor in their return to the World Series for the […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read