Expert prediction
NFL Comeback Player of the Year Outright Odds 2025
Pick rationale
Analysis & key factors
- NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds highlight three names.
- Joe Burrow is the reigning winner, and that’s his second trophy.
- Five of the last six winners were quarterbacks.
Everyone loves a good comeback. That’s why this award generates so much hype and is one of the favorites for both players and fans.
Before you start reading, here are the odds for all NFL awards.
NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds
| Player | Odds |
|---|---|
| Aidan Hutchinson | +300 |
| Christian McCaffrey | +350 |
| Dak Prescott | +375 |
| Trevor Lawrence | +700 |
| JJ McCarthy | +800 |
| Rashee Rice | +1400 |
| Maxx Crosby | +2000 |
Hutchinson and McCaffrey Lead the Way
Detroit Lions’ DE and the former 2nd pick, fractured his fibula and tibia last season in Week 6, missing the remainder of the campaign. He was on pace to produce his best career stats, and is surely eager to pick up where he left off.
On the other hand, we don’t need to emphasize how important CMC was to the 49ers. He is one of the most versatile offensive players of the last two decades, and his numbers are simply not realistic. His ligament injury caused him to end the season without a single touchdown, a year after he won the NFL Offensive Player of the Year award.
Dak’s and Trevor’s Soulsearching
These two guys are in limbo right now. If they have good seasons, they will be elite once again. But if they don’t, they just might sink into mediocrity. Prescott got the fluke label when it comes to playoffs, while Lawrence might be one of the biggest busts in the Jags’ history if he fails to deliver now.
Both had terrible seasons last year and are expected to show up and bounce back in the 2025 NFL campaign.
McCarthy, Rice, Crosby, maybe Diggs
One by one, names like JJ McCarthy, Rashee Rice, and Maxx Crosby are on the NFL Comeback Player of the Year contenders list. There’s one name that stands out in our opinion, and that’s Stefon Diggs. He is in New England now, eager to step on the field following his ACL tear in the previous season.
NFL
More Predictions
NFL Week 9 Upsets: Commanders Nasty Underdogs, Cardinals and Raiders Defending the Spread
Week 9 of the 2026 NFL season features several situational spots where short underdogs hold tactical, scheduling, or matchup advantages. There aren’t as many choices as in previous rounds, but there’s still enough for us bettors to make some money. Here is one straight-up upset pick and two point-spread underdog picks, backed by key tactical […]
NFL Week 9 Player Props: Pitts to Score a TD, Flournoy Continues to Grow
NFL Week 9 player props are here. We’ve waited to see the situation regarding potential absences and injuries, and with game day just around the corner, it was time to unleash the best player prop picks for this round. We have three selections for our bettors, carefully picked and evaluated following a thorough process. After […]
Broncos vs. Panthers Week 9 Picks: Young’s Poor Protection Will Cost Carolina
Best bet: Broncos ATS pick: Broncos -2.5 Bet Broncos vs. Panthers at BetUS Denver Broncos (6-2) hit the road to face the Carolina Panthers (3-4) and continue their excellent run. The Panthers have been on the downhill lately and are under pressure to win this game and get back to the winning side. Stay with […]
Giants vs. Eagles Week 9 Picks: Rested Giants After a Win in Philly
Best bet: Giants ATS pick: Giants -3.5 Bet Giants vs. Eagles at BetUS NFC East is completely wild these days. The New York Giants (4-2-1) lead the group, while the Philadelphia Eagles (2-6) sit last. The home team is in huge trouble, having multiple stars out due to injuries. The Giants also have some absences, […]
Browns vs. Saints Week 9 Picks: Indoor Arena Will Create Problems for Cleveland
Best bet: Saints -1.5 Straight up pick: Saints moneyline Bet Cardinals vs Cowboys at BetUS Cleveland Browns (5-3) are still in the mix for the playoffs. However, they will need to win in New Orleans against the Saints (2-5). Browns are very light underdogs here, sitting at +100 before we started writing this article. We […]