Expert prediction
MLB: Pirates vs Rays Odds, and Prop Bets (May 4)
- Keith McCarthy
- May 3, 2023 at 9:58 PM EDT
Pick rationale
Analysis & key factors
- Pittsburgh has had a fantastic start, currently sitting at 20-10.
- The Rays continue to be the best team in the entire MLB, at 24-6.
- Tampa Bay is 10-9 in their all-time history against the Pittsburgh Pirates.
The Pirates and the Rays face off in an interesting interleague bout. Both teams have surpassed their expectations so far this season, earning 1st place spots in their divisions. There are key bets on both sides.
How to Watch
- Where: Tropicana Field, St. Petersburg, FL
- When: Thursday, May 4, 2023, at 1:10 p.m ET
- How to Watch: Bally Sports
Prop Bets
| Prop Bet | Odds |
| Conner Joe Over 0.5 Hits | |
| Conner Joe Under 0.5 Hits |
Prediction:
Conner Joe has had a fantastic start to the 2023 season. He is currently hitting .298, and has an OPS of .987, which ranks 12th in all of Major League Baseball. Joe is taking full advantage of his increased role in his first season with the Pirates. He’s gotten a hit in 4 of his last 5 games, and reached base in all 5. In Tuesday’s loss against the Rays, Joe went 2 for 4. I like his chances of getting another hit in this game.
Pick:
| Prop Bet | Odds |
| Bryan Reynolds Over 0.5 RBIs | |
| Bryan Reynolds Under 0.5 RBIs |
Prediction:
Bryan Reynolds is also having a key impact for the Pirates in their hot start, ranking 8th in the MLB with a .330 batting average, and a strong .957 OPS. Reynolds has followed a strange pattern over his career. In odd seasons (2019, 2021, 2023), he batted .315 with a .916 OPS. In even seasons (2020, 2022), he batted .225 with an OPS of .720. Injuries played a role in that, but I see Reynolds continuing his strong 2023 here.

Pick:
| Prop Bet | Odds |
| Zach Eflin Over 5.5 Strikeouts | |
| Zach Eflin Under 5.5 Strikeouts |
Prediction:
Zach Eflin has pitched very well so far this season, giving up 7 earned runs in 21 IP, equivalent to a 3.00 ERA. Eflin hasn’t had the best length, throwing an average of 74 pitches in his 4 starts thus far. This has resulted in a lower strikeout total, despite his strong performances. Against a Pirates team that has been strong on offense all season so far, I see Eflin pitching relatively well, but failing to amass more than 5 K’s.
Pick:
MLB
More Predictions
World Series: Rays vs. Brewers Game 4 Picks, Odds & Betting Analysis
There is a sense of inevitability in the 2026 World Series, as Milwaukee Brewers require just one more victory to win the biggest MLB honor for the first time. History will be against the Tampa Bay Rays, as no team has ever recovered from 3-0 down to win the World Series. You can find the […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read
World Series: Rays vs. Brewers Game 3 Picks, Odds & Betting Analysis
The intense action in the World Series steps up a gear on Monday, as the first game of the series to see the Tampa Bay Rays have home-field advantage will be staged. It will be a must-win encounter for the hosts, following defeats in Games 1 and 2 at American Family Field. A victory for […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read
World Series: Brewers vs. Rays Game 2 Picks, Odds & Betting Analysis
The intensity increases in the World Series on Saturday evening, as Game 2 between the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays is set for American Family Field. Milwaukee will be hoping for a fast start in their opening two games, but the Rays have been consistent on their travels in the postseason. The latest odds […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read
World Series: Brewers vs. Rays Game 1 Picks, Odds & Betting Analysis
The high-pressure action in the MLB reaches new heights on Oct. 23, as the 2026 World Series gets underway. Both the Tampa Bay Rays and Milwaukee Brewers will be targeting first honors, and whichever team deals with the pressure the best will likely seize the advantage. The Brewers will have the Game 1 home-field advantage, and you […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read
World Series 2026: Brewers vs. Rays Picks, Series Odds & Betting Analysis
History awaits in the MLB postseason, as a first-time World Series champion will be crowned in 2026. The Tampa Bay Rays are hoping that it’s their third time lucky, having lost in the 2008 and 2020 World Series, while the Milwaukee Brewers chase a first honor in their return to the World Series for the […]
AAlex Dudley 3 min read