Tottenham vs. Everton Picks, Odds, Props, and EPL Betting Analysis — Goal-Shy Spurs to Come Undone Against Resilient Toffees? 

• Tottenham have failed to win in three EPL outings in 2026-27.
• Everton are unbeaten in the Premier League this season.
• Spurs have lost just once in their last 17 home fixtures against the Toffees.

Tottenham will be aiming to snap a poor start to the Premier League this weekend when they host Everton. Spurs will be favored at the best soccer betting sites, but could their poor home form make them vulnerable? Find our Tottenham vs. Everton picks here.  

Tottenham vs. Everton Odds

Match Result	Odds
Tottenham	+107
The Draw	+266
Everton	+258
Total Goals: Over/Under 2.5	-107/-113

How to Watch

• When: Saturday, September 12, 2026. 12:30 PM ET
• Where: Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, London, England
• How to Watch: NBC, Peacock

ALSO SEE: NFL Week 1: Cardinals vs. Chargers Preview, Odds, Predictions (Sep 13)

Tottenham vs. Everton EPL Preview

Spurs Struggling Despite Heavy Summer Investment

Roberto De Zerbi admitted that there would be no quick fix at Tottenham this season, despite a heavy summer of investment. That appears to be true based on the team’s performances in 2026-27, as Spurs are winless in the opening three rounds.

An attacking output was a major concern in last weekend’s 0-0 draw against Nottingham Forest, as Spurs failed to register a single shot on target in the stalemate. Savio was one of the big summer arrivals, and his return to fitness could be crucial to their chances on Saturday, as the Brazilian registered two goal involvements in a debut showing against Charlton in the EFL Cup.

Finding the right balance will be the big question for De Zerbi, with Dominic Solanke likely to be recalled to provide a direct threat in the central striker position.

Likely Lineup:

(4-2-3-1) Kinsky (GK); Porro, van Hecke, van de Ven, Udogie; Tonali, Bentancur; Savio, Kudus, Marmoush; Solanke

Toffees Enjoying Reliable Start to New Season

David Moyes has overseen an encouraging start to the new Premier League season at Everton, as the Toffees are unbeaten in the opening three rounds of fixtures.

Plenty of confidence would have been gained from their late draw against Man United last Sunday, with Ainsley Maitland-Niles scoring a dramatic equalizer on his Everton debut. There will be pressure on Thierno Barry to stay fit, as Everton failed to bring in a new striker in the summer transfer window.

The forward has been in reliable scoring form so far this term, netting four in as many appearances in all competitions. The Toffees will likely be without injured midfielders James Garner and Christian Norgaard this weekend.

Likely Lineup:

(4-2-3-1) Pickford (GK); Maitland-Niles, Tarkowski, Branthwaite, Mykolenko; Armstrong, Hackney; Johnson, Dewsbury-Hall, Grealish; Barry

Head-to-Head Stats

• Tottenham have suffered just one home defeat in their last 17 against the Toffees.
• Everton lost both meetings against Spurs without scoring in 2025-26.
• Everton’s last away league win against Spurs was a 1-0 victory in September 2020.

Tottenham vs. Everton EPL Picks

Tottenham have endured a miserable start to the new season, and their attacking output will be a major concern. The fact that they are hard to trust is difficult to overlook when making Tottenham vs. Everton picks, meaning that a positive result for the Toffees away from home could be an interesting value play.

• The Draw (+266)

Tottenham vs. Everton Props Picks

Everton’s defensive strength should be respected this weekend, while Tottenham’s inability to score also supports the chances of a low-scoring encounter. As a player props pick, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall should be considered. The attacking midfielder averages 1.33 shots per game and has an impressive shot conversion rate of 20.51%.

• The Draw, Under 2.5 Goals & Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall to Score (+2500)