Everton vs. Man City Picks – Betting Preview, Team News, Predictions, and Prop Pick (May 4) 

• When: Monday, May 4, 2026. 3:00 AM ET
• Where: Hill Dickinson Stadium, Liverpool, England
• How to Watch: NBC

Match Result	Odds
Everton	+560
The Draw	+415
Man City	-222

Everton vs. Man City Preview

The attention switches back to the English Premier League title race on April 4, as Man City bid to close the gap on Arsenal at the summit. Pep Guardiola’s side are in red-hot form, but Everton will still have European aspirations of their own in the final month of the campaign.

ALSO SEE: Kentucky Derby Picks – Horse Racing Odds, Betting Preview, and Predictions (May 2)

Everton Stats & Team News

• Overall Record: 13-8-13
• Home Record: 6-4-7
• Road Record: 7-4-6

David Moyes will be hoping for a response from his Everton side on Monday, as the Toffees have suffered defeats in back-to-back Premier League fixtures. Everton have dropped to eleventh in the standings, but they remain just two points adrift of the top seven.

A response is likely, as the Toffees haven’t suffered three on the bounce since January 2025. However, they will need to see out of their fixtures better after conceding 90^th minute winners in their previous two.

Team News:

Beto (Head), Jarrad Branthwaite (Thigh)

Likely Line-Up:

(4-2-3-1): Pickford (GK); O’Brien, Tarkowski, Keane, Mykolenko; Gueye, Garner, Ndiaye, Dewsbury-Hall, McNeil; Barry

Man City Stats & Team News

• Overall Record: 21-7-5
• Home Record: 12-3-1
• Road Record: 9-4-4

The pressure in the Premier League title race will be back on Man City on Monday, and they could kick off at the Hill Dickinson Stadium trailing Arsenal by as many as six points.

However, their form is extremely reliable, having avoided defeat in their last eleven EPL fixtures, and conceding just eight goals over that period. No side in the competition have picked up more points and conceded fewer goals over the same period.

Team News:

Rodri (Groin), Ruben Dias (Muscle), Josko Gvardiol (Leg)

Likely Line-Up:

(4-2-3-1): Donnarumma (GK); Nunes, Khusanov, Guehi, Ait-Nouri; Silva, Gonzalez; Semenyo, Cherki, Doku; Haaland

Head-to-Head Trends

• Everton have suffered defeats in each of their last eight home matches against Man City.
• Man City have avoided defeat in their last 17 EPL fixtures against Everton, recording 14 wins and picking up three draws.

Everton vs. Man City Prop Picks

Jeremy Doku could be a key player in the final third for Man City on Monday. The winger has registered four assists to Erling Haaland in 2025-26, and only Callum Hudson-Odoi has created more chances following dribbles than Doku (24).

• Jeremy Doku to Register 1+ Assists vs. Everton with BetOnline

Everton vs. Man City Picks

There is unlikely to be a twist in the Premier League title race on Monday. Man City have been in excellent recent form, while Everton have looked fatigued. City’s dominant head-to-head advantage over the Toffees is also impossible to dismiss.

• Man City @ -222 with BetOnline