Skip to content

Expert prediction

James Madison vs Marshall Odds, and Picks (Oct 19)

  • Keith McCarthy
  • Oct 18, 2023 at 4:57 PM EDT

Pick rationale

Analysis & key factors

  • James Madison improved to 6-0 with a 41-13 win over Georgia Southern.
  • Marshall lost their second straight game, falling 41-24 to Georgia State.
  • These two teams last met on October 22, 2022, in a game Marshall won 26-12.

The college football season is in full swing. Let’s preview the upcoming James Madison vs Marshall game. The Dukes are just outside of the top-25, as one of the final undefeated teams. They’ll try to stay perfect.


How to Watch

  • ESPN

Preview

As the nation’s current #26 team and one of the final 11 unbeaten teams, James Madison is looking for a chance to prove themselves even further. A win this week over Marshall should be enough for them to reach the official rankings. Unfortunately, they are not eligible for a bowl game or conference title due to arcane NCAA rules. They will be eligible next season, though, and may even fight for the G5’s CFP spot.

After a 4-0 start to the year, Marshall has now fallen to 4-2. Competitive road losses to NC State and 5-1 Georgia State aren’t terribly disappointing, but the Thundering Herd are still itching to get back in the win column. They have a chance to knock off a quasi-ranked team this week in James Madison, with more tough road games at Coastal Carolina and App State nearing. They need the defense to bounce back.


Prediction

I’m tempted to take a Marshall team here that is too good for an extended losing streak. It’s a bit hard to imagine them losing 3 or more games in a row. That being said, their schedule is tough enough for it to happen, with James Madison representing the toughest test of them all. The Thundering Herd should benefit from being at home, but I still like the Dukes to win this game and improve to 7-0 on the season.

NCAAF Picks:

  • James Madison 26, Marshall 20 ()

NCAAF

More Predictions

NCAAF Insight

FCS Picks: #3 Montana #13 Northern Arizona Odds & Prediction (Oct 10)

In this week’s FCS picks, we’ll break down the Montana vs Northern Arizona matchup, featuring a battle of top-15 teams. The Grizzlies enter as the favorite, despite being on the road. They will be aiming to improve to 39-15 against Northern Arizona all-time. Montana Looks to Keep Rolling Montana enters this game having historically dominated […]

Keith McCarthy 2 min read

NCAAF Insight

FCS Picks: #2 Tarleton State vs #8 Austin Peay Odds & Prediction (Oct 10)

In this week’s FCS picks, we’ll break down the Tarleton State vs Austin Peay matchup, featuring a battle of top-10 teams. They played a thriller last season in a 45-44 result, and are likely to hold another very competitive high-stakes matchup in this rematch. Tarleton State Eyes FCS Top Spot Tarleton State is one of […]

Keith McCarthy 2 min read

NCAAF Insight

NCAAF: #5 Ohio State vs #14 Iowa Preview, Odds, Picks (Oct 3)

In this week’s Ohio State vs Iowa matchup, the Buckeyes and Hawkeyes face off in an undefeated battle. Ohio State is heavily favored, despite being on the road. They opened the season at #1 in the country but have since fallen to #5, aiming to rise back up. Ohio State Seeks to Continue Rising Ohio […]

Keith McCarthy 2 min read

NCAAF Insight

NCAAF: #7 Alabama vs #16 Mississippi State Preview, Odds, Picks (Oct 3)

In this week’s Alabama vs Mississippi State matchup a pair of top SEC teams faces off in a top-20 matchup. The Crimson Tide are favored to win on the road but face a challenge against a rough Bulldogs team. The winner will rise to 5-0 and the top of the SEC. Alabama Seeking to Rise […]

Keith McCarthy 2 min read

NCAAF Insight

College Football Gameday Picks: Best Straight-Up Predictions and Odds (Sep 26)

The rankings continue to change as we enter Week 4 of the college football season. There are plenty of great odds and picks to bet on this week, so don’t miss our predictions for this week’s top-5 matchups straight-up. Best Straight-Up College Football Picks UCLA vs Maryland UCLA opened the season 3-0, but should be […]

Keith McCarthy 2 min read